Why two Kundli sites disagree
Short answer
Two Kundli sites disagree because of six things: a different ayanamsa (Lahiri, KP or Raman), true versus mean node for Rahu and Ketu, whole-sign versus Bhava Chalit houses, time zone or daylight-time handling, the place's coordinates, and rounding near a sign boundary. Different settings are choices, not errors; different inputs mean one chart is wrong.
Cast your free Kundli
What makes two charts for the same birth differ?
| Cause | What differs | What it can change |
|---|---|---|
| Ayanamsa | Lahiri, KP and Raman use different values: KP sits within a few arcminutes of Lahiri, Raman about one and a half degrees away | Every planet and the Lagna shift by the same small amount; near a boundary, a sign, nakshatra or dasha can change |
| Rahu and Ketu | True node or mean node, up to about 1.5 degrees apart | Rahu's nakshatra, sometimes its sign, and close Kaal Sarp calls |
| House system | Whole-sign houses or Bhava Chalit | Which house a planet falls in, and so checks such as Manglik |
| Time zone or daylight time | The offset applied to the clock time | One hour's error moves the Lagna by about half a sign |
| Place coordinates | A town's own coordinates, a district's, or a wrong match | Each degree of longitude is 4 minutes of local time, which moves the Lagna |
| Rounding | How degrees are rounded for display | A planet at the very end of a sign can be shown in the next one |
The first three are settings. The next two are inputs. The last is presentation.
Can you show a worked example?
A made-up example, not a real person. The same birth details are entered on two sites.
- Site A, using the Lahiri ayanamsa, puts the Moon at 6°35' Libra.
- Site B, using a different ayanamsa, puts it a few arcminutes further on, at 6°45' Libra.
Chitra nakshatra ends at 6°40' Libra. So Site A shows the Moon in Chitra, whose lord is Mars, and a first Mahadasha of Mars (7 years). Site B shows the Moon in Swati, whose lord is Rahu, and a first Mahadasha of Rahu (18 years). From a difference of ten arcminutes, every dasha date in the two reports is different.
Neither site made an arithmetic mistake. They follow different conventions, and the Moon happened to sit on a boundary.
A second common case: Mars sits near the edge of a house. A whole-sign chart puts it in the 7th; a Bhava Chalit chart puts it in the 8th. Both are Manglik houses, but if the shift were from the 7th to the 6th, one site would call the chart Manglik and the other would not.
Which site is right?
If the inputs are the same and correct, each chart is right for its own settings. The real question is which convention you want to follow. Janmagyan uses the Lahiri (Chitrapaksha) ayanamsa, whole-sign houses and the mean node. Practitioners of KP use the KP ayanamsa; some follow Raman.
If the inputs differ, though, one chart is simply wrong. A wrong time zone, a missed daylight-time adjustment, or a place matched to the wrong town is an error, and the fix is to correct the input.
How do I compare two sites fairly?
- Enter exactly the same date, time and place on both, and check the am/pm.
- Check the time zone each site applied, and the coordinates it used for the place.
- Find each site's settings: ayanamsa, node, house system. Compare only like with like.
- Compare the Lagna degree and the Moon's degree first. If these match, the rest usually will.
- If a planet or the Lagna is within a degree or so of a boundary, expect sites to disagree about it, and treat that placement as uncertain.
What can this not settle?
Which tradition is true. Choosing Lahiri over KP, or whole-sign houses over Bhava Chalit, is a matter of school and practice, not of calculation, and no comparison of sites can decide it. What a comparison can do is show you which differences come from settings and which come from a wrong input.
How Janmagyan computes this
Janmagyan computes your chart exactly from your birth date, time and place, using the Lahiri (Chitrapaksha) ayanamsa, whole-sign houses, and the mean lunar node for Rahu and Ketu. Its engine was checked against the Swiss Ephemeris on 13 test births from 1947 to 2024: planets agree within 20 arcseconds and the Lagna within 30 arcseconds. It shows each planet's degree, so you can see when a placement sits close to a boundary.
Enter your details in the free chart and compare its Lagna and Moon degrees with any other site, setting for setting.